To Herbert Grubel The ways rescue ruined Canada Frank Li May 6, 2026 The West has never humanized in ruining the life of world people. Attached two articles in the end 1...Professor Grubel: Canada should not open its door to the world 2...PM Mark Carney: Don’t hope that the U.S. will return to normal Note: Given the rapid increase in readership, it's clear everyone is concerning this issue. I'm continuously adding content to help reader understand the essence of the issue. Now, PM Mark Carney is a leader in changing the outdated unlivable world, not through power, but through rational thoughts based on his studies and significant professional experience. However, based on Europeans loot-kill made freedom fueled egoistic culture, the democratic systems, relied ideologies, legal systems, and so on, all support liberal behavior. Immigration lawyers, human rights lawyers, etc., can file lawsuits that can force judges to halt deportation of criminals, construction projects, etc., which will kill all efforts of PM Mark Carney. This is a result of the historical accumulation of West, and it is difficult to change because it affects interests of people. So, we must use method that does not directly impact individual interests. As a gentle spring breeze, the civilization of China is able to peacefully humanize liberal democracy and medication. 1...Humanize democracy 2000 years ago, China explored Silk Road, now updated as Belt Road to survive people in West; but they kill until this moment. Due to that China chooses learned people in power; also in 134BC, firstly held Imperial Examination to choose talent throughout country, later it was institutionalized once a year until 1905. Europe missionaries call it as the elite constitution that values merit over the birth to give power to scholars. Today China is in Technocratic Democracy by quality entrepreneurs, scientists, engineers, etc., part time self-reliant as lawmakers; the top leadership is a politburo of 7 members promoted from grassroots; without meeting consensus; no one allowed to talk at will; by which institutional constraints avoided the development of the personal dictatorship under strict accountability. Nowadays, social governance has evolved as that of lawmakers make policies as orbit; and then the society runs accordingly, which is that lawmakers make laws to make the in-executable power of the State Apparatus as executable true and is able to play the practical role to govern the country. The State Apparatus is equipped with the police officers and prisons to compel the people who dared defy the laws. Once the policies are enacted, the State Apparatus will automatically enforce them. This made an actuality; who works as lawmaker; whom gained ability to reform governance. We must integrate the Technocratic Democracy of China to humanize the democracy of Canada. However, social progress will involve the redistribution of interests to cause unrest. In this concern; the acceptable way is to keep the current political body as it is and avoid touching the interest of current lawmakers and politicians in power, and then based on which; to learn the Technocratic Democracy of China by choosing outstanding elites in part time self reliance as lawmakers. In Canada, we may take Business Council of Canada as headquarter to set an E-office by its member entrepreneurs joint with the social elites from whole Canada in part time self reliance as lawmakers form a civil legislature; and take 30% vote right to parallel run with the Gov-one to patching the flaws of democracy. With the non-partisan advantage of the civil legislature, it needn’t care about pleasing voters, and it needn’t care about the political correctness; which is able to get rid of the fatal harm of democratic politics; so that the civil legislature is able to propose some policies that populism politicians dared not proposed. In this indirect roundabout way, without touching the political body, without causing unrest; by people respected professors and social elites in part time self reliance work as lawmakers, the formation of the civil legislature will be no one dared to oppose; which is the only feasible way that will be widely acceptable. 2...Humanize medication By TCM philosophy of China humanizes western medicine, thereby viewing patients as emotional humans from viewed as non-human assembly, then cures patients by essential nutrients timely repairing the ill and aging lesions from killing & genetic patching to restore health for disease free healthy 120 years. Vinegar can destruct all viruses to uproot infectious disease; regulating ill & aging led abnormal physiological indicators to normal. Melatonin can regenerate the ill and aging damaged cells of nerves, immune, kidney failure and more, to restore the system, vinegar + melatonin is able to erase the concept of incurable. Under TCM philosophy; it is no incurable diseases at all, Alzheimer's, diabetes...; are all curable; even not happen. Water diluting 5%vinegar x 18ml (0.9g pure)/50 kg or 2x500mg vinegar capsules/50kg is able to cure or prevent fever and coughs of flu in any cause; and makes any disease patients' symptoms relieved. Adds melanin 5mg – 10mg will cure diabetes, Alzheimer's, etc. to uproot the evil mind of incurable diseases of western medicine. By cheaper safer vinegar and melatonin; people self help cure diseases and reduce the morbidity will reduce the reliance of people on hospitals; which is the only way to improve healthcare in big saving. Otherwise, no matter how big a sum of money that the government invested will be useless; besides wasted money, because western medicine is kicking away the effective medication by the name of unscientific. --- May 8, 2026 <<<<<<<<<<<>>>>>>>>>>
Main topic This is updated email I sent to Professor Herbert Grubel on May 2, 2026 by subject: The ways to rescue democracy ruined Canada. This topic inspired by the interview Professor reveals what Canadians aren't being told about Carney. The interviewee is Dr. Eric KaufmannIn, political scientist and currently a Professor at Buckingham University in the UK. 2024, Dr. Eric KaufmannIn published book The third awokening: A 12-point plan for rolling back progressive extremism, to argue that awakening culture is not a passing fad, but a cultural revolution. The Western world is suffering a third wave of cultural left-wing ideological fervor, which leads to a surge in crime, a deteriorating education system, border chaos, and social division. Dr. Eric KaufmannIn indicated the danger with solution, the current awakening extremism is not a rejection of liberalism, but a distorted extension of it. Our only way out is to use the power of elected, constitutionally granted governments to thoroughly intervene in our institutions and culture. Above was the key point of the interview and the book. Live Canada for 25 years, saw too much absurd ridiculous things as that talked in the interview and book, with the cultural background of China, I've been wondering that what exactly is in the heads of Westerners? Though Dr. Eric KaufmannIn is rare rational for seeing the problem, but he cannot see the essence of the probelm as a Westerner. Actually, the disaster was just stemmed from “the power of elected, constitutionally granted governments”; it is precisely the elected democratic politicians who must please voters and support the play of awakening culture. In this concern, May 6, 2026, I wrote Mandarin article Ambitious Canadian PM Mark Carney is destined to be defeated by beastly culture. Now I write this topic, adds explanations of the solutions to humanize antihuman democracy; to post email I sent to Professor Herbert Grubel on May 2, 2026 by the subject: The ways to rescue democracy ruined Canada. Herbert Gunter Grubel (Feb 26, 1934 -) is a Canadian professor, economist, writer, and former politician. He is Professor Emeritus of Economics at Simon Fraser University and a Senior Fellow at the Fraser Institute. May 2 2026, I sent Prof. below email moved by the video that he accepted interview and showed his worry for ruined Canada I cry for you, Canada: 92-year-old prof and ex-MP’s warning about immigration & welfare state. As earlier in Oct 1, 2015, Prof. Herbert Grubel has published article titled Canada should not open its doors to the world, to have indicated bad consequence: An influx of new immigrants could bankrupt our welfare state. I think of 2015 Mandarin article that French Le Figaro described series of Europe local born terrorists makes terror attacks as "ISIS war on Europe." Europe enters the Era of terrorism, made countless civilians victims. Europeans self-frugal costly feed human rights commissioners; but they brainlessly force European countries to accept illegal immigrants. The illegal immigrants mostly came from India, Latin America, and Africa; of those countries where are in the uncivilized semi-cave state. Such uncivilized ones cannot be trained as law-abiding citizens or constructors, but skilled in making crimes and ruin the life of Canadians. Please Google Mr.Jayant Bhandari, a India born indian; he said that Indian values consider it wise to commit crimes without being caught. Indian social culture lacks concepts of honor, contracts, friendship, and respect. India is a country without a sense of honor; you absolutely cannot trust anyone. Such ignorant culture was rooted in the unique history. India willingly been swept by foreign civilizations several times, it has accumulated all of the garbage of the world's civilizations. Various absurd ideologies and religions are rampant, and itself is good at creating toxic local ones to dehumanize people; bridges built collapsed, dams built crumbled, whatever they do has ruined. Now, the birth rate in developed countries is lower than the replacement rate, while the uncivilized countries are producing large numbers of low-quality people who migrate around the world to make racial replacment.
In Canada, a white man video complained that his wife was giving birth, but the hospital had no delivery beds available, were mostly occupied by Indians. I saw a post said that in France 65% new born is dark skin. Now some Indians yell that Canada is their country, the white people must go back to Europe and now in Canada, Indians vigorously transplant their culture, rligions; gangs; that have been making India stay uncilized.
Boeing passenger planes are once a source of pride for American manufacturing and as a mode of transportation trusted by people all over the world, its founding technical expert was a man from China. However, in recent years, Boeing has experienced a series of accidents, it said that due to hired Indian on management positions, and also the software made by Indians.
PM Mark Carney is outstanding politician globally, and his proposed infrastructure investment plan is correct, needed and feasible. However, Canada has uprooted foundation to complete the infrastructure projects. Currently, apart from well cultured highly qualified people of China, no any people in other country can complete infrastructure projects within budgeted in funds and times. No made in China; no one is able to live well. Given Canada's superior conditions, it should only accept outstanding immigrants. However, Canada is now being destroyed by inferior immigrants, and caused its own quality elites flee away at an accelerated pace. When Professor made warning in Oct 1, 2015, Canada has no such problem, the warning made according to the disasters in the Europe. Today; the sad worries and wise warning of professor Herbert Grubel has been developed disaster true. Needless to say the over filled immigrats. The number of asylum must feed by Canadians has reached 500,000. A criminal ordered deported by a judge can continue to live in Canada and enjoy free feed from Canadians if he applies in asylum status. On 2026, Canada finally admits Indian investigations indicated that Canada has become a command center for Indian gangs Khalistani. In West, the legal system is also beast, with human rights experts and immigration experts maks living by abusing laws harm Canadians. Now, there increasingly Canadians are dying from no treatment available; but the cost of healthcare on asylum has reached one billion. Even more sinister is bringing evil religions ruining the world. It has reported, in Canada; some schools have to ban kids bring lunches with pork; PM Mark Carney also has to declare that Muslims values are Canadian values; which proved disaster that religion has successfully dehumanized the culture of Canada and made Canadian live in the fear of life threats. This is the reason that 92-years-old Professor Herbert Gunter Grubel cry for the ruin of Canada; which should be avoided as he warned. I Google found that Professor Herbert Grubel has written many prophetic warning articles. Unfortunately, in countries that play democracy, politicians only care about pleasing voters and do not care about other things. Canada has been flooded in so many immigrants and asylum; because politicians play with human rights for pleasing voters win vote. Now, I am tearful for the sad feeling of Professor Herbert Grubel; because that I once also suffered the similiar miserable experience. On 2020, I conducted a meat food plant DC Foods Waterloo Canada in zero Covid infection, since then I have sent hundreds emails, even bought a Fax Machine to fax to WHO, officials globally, but useless. Otherwise Covid-19 would not out of control and killed 20 million to destroled world economy. Ses my article The emails that I sent for ending pandemic Covid-19. I copied the article of Prof. Herbert Grubel in the end of the topic. My advice to my dear compatriots from my motherland I notice that the half of my blog readers come after the midnight of Canada; I guess they are from my motherland. I add this paragraph. Since ancient time, the West took power as gift for competing to be seized by beasts; modern democracy has been doing the same. Now Western countries are finished beyond saving; because that they can't abandon democratic politics to prevent their regimes from being seized and dictated by beasts. Look at America, now it is dictated by the one who is both a beast and a psychopath. Since ancient time China has been choosing learned people in power, for which even developed Imperial Examination selecting learned talents govern the country. In fact, the feudal system is a kind of stable institutional cornerstone or political umbrella in safeguarding a peaceful society; so that Imperial Examination can be sustained and ensured the rational people in power. Today, the Communist Party of China is the leading party, which plays the role of a political umbrella and then selects quality elites to govern the country. Today, China is by quality entrepreneurs, scientists, engineers, etc., as lawmakers in part time self-reliant; the top leadership is a politburo of 7 members promoted from grassroots gradually; without consensus from meeting; no one allowed to talk at will; by which institutional constraints avoided the development of the personal dictatorship under strict accountability. In 2019, China's Overrated Technocrats said: Western parliaments are dominated by people with law degrees, but leaders of China, there 8 out of 9 officials are scientists and engineers. This is reason that in 2000 years ago China explored the Silk Road, today updated as the Belt Road to survive people in the West, but they kill at home yard; and then worldwide, until this moment still kill in the Middle East and Ukraine. However, our governance needs improvement in many areas. We prioritize the number of officials being punished as optical achievement; in reality, it is the sign of the failure in governance; due to that no laws to conduct the behavior of people; so that made good people as prisoner. I noticed that many people who study literature have been appointed to important leadership positions, which is a mistake. Due to the brain of such people filled with the bestial culture of the West, will destroy our motherland. Especially, those who study economics and law are social scum, a scourge to our motherland. Includes Humanities, History, Philosophy, etc.
金一南将军救救被西方文化兽性化的畜生毁灭的祖国 被西方文化兽性化从教育根基上摧毁祖国
西方兽性文化兽性化的经济学家又害中国 追根溯源 是谁让同胞们生活于犯罪猖獗的恐惧中 中国政府的移民管理官员正在加速度地摧毁祖国
The evil root that Europe was ruined as garbage place Sept 28, 2022, in the Keynote address at the 10th annual Athens Democracy Forum, President Von der leyen said that it is every generation's task to fight for democracy. The reason why Von der Leyen wants every generation's task to fight for democracy, because playing democracy, she can waste life money of people for self enjoyment. In order to avoid war, European countries promoted integration and established a large European Union with a unified euro currency. However, democracy favors the selfish play of humans has turned the EU into a tool for creating disasters and destroyed the life of Europeans by well fed of Europeans. Jan 2019, article EU on the brink: German eurosceptics threaten 'DEXIT' unless EU parliament is ABOLISHED reports that the European Parliament has 751 MEPs, 44,000 officials and 11,000 employees that cost over �8billion a year; 4,000 of them earn more than �290,000 a year in more than of Angela Merkel’s salary. May 2014, article Luxury EU Junkets for MEPs Cost Taxpayer Over euro 5m a Year reports that the "Members of the European Parliament have been spending more than �5m a year on alleged “fact finding” trips to some of the most luxurious destinations on the world and they were accompanied with the team of servants. Jan 2023, article The EU's "crazy salary increase" caused controversy, von der Leyen's daily salary exceeded 1,000 euros reports that as people across the European Union are struggling with high inflation, EU officials crazy increase salary, 50,000 EU employees can expect a second salary increase in 7 % within 6 months, salary plus allowances, von der Lein's total income is about 36,000 euros per month in daily salary exceeds 1,000 euros. The salary increases are borne by taxpayers, but under inflation, the salary of ordinary German workers has not adjusted. The EU wastes the life-saving money of Europeans to well feed the Human Rights Commissioner; and the Commissioner purposefully ruins the life of Europeans. In the name of protecting human rights, they force governments to accept and feed illegal immigrants, causing trouble and making it impossible for Europeans to make a living. For protecting human rights, they support people strikes for more by doing less in unearned and ruined the quality of workers for making survival materials. It was the generation that suffered WWII, who was lived frugally and worked wholeheartedly to have created the prosperity of the West. Now they have left, the West has lost its survival foundation. It was democratic politicians forcing people fight for democracy in making refugees; while human rights protect Freedom of Belief, a large number of low-quality populations are growing wildly as illegal immigrants wandering around the world; and then European hard working feeding European Commission of Human Rights enforce European countries allowing free inflowing of illegal immigrants and make Europeans lived valueless without a dignity as human. Taxpayers cost so much to establish such a complex political system; by own hard earned money in self living frugally to feed so many lawmakers; got reward of an unlivable homeland. This is not limited in the EU; there were reports of democratic politicians raised payments when people going to starve. Now Germany is governing by red and green lights of an unhinged political compass creates chaos to ruin own home yard. It said that in addition to Russia and Ukraine, the biggest loser in the Russo-Ukrainian war was Germany. Germany was not only suffered an economic loss of 200 billion euros, but also it became one of the worst-performing major economies in the world last year. At the same time, Germany has once again been labeled the "sick man of Europe". Please look at that how Germans play their democracy. According to Grand coalition (Germany) - Wikipedia that was last edited on 18 April 2019, after the inconclusive result of the 2005 German federal election, neither of the traditional coalitions could form a majority government. Another possible coalition existed, comprising the SPD, Greens, and the Party of Democratic Socialism (PDS), PDS, the successor party to East Germany's ruling Socialist Unity Party, the SPD, CDU/CSU to agree to form a grand coalition with CDU leader Angela Merkel as chancellor and an equal number of cabinet seats for each party. I really doubt that whether the great Germans themselves can quickly sort out these political parties and their sacred political goals; and eventually; what on earth; they want to do and what actually they are able to provide for Germans. It was European Ancestors kindly made democracy & valuable ideologies making contributions. The great contribution of European ancestors was successful distorted the cognitions of people. Only humanized Europeans work as lawmaker is able to make a humanized life for Europeans. The awakening culture is caused by hormone disorders To understand Awakening Culture, May 7, 2026, I wrote Political correctness made the West play ignorance Ever since the French people hanged their king; the democracies have been running under the people, who make living by playing with political correctness to hunt and destroy the political career of the politicians who dared defy the imposed toxic ideologies values, freedom and human rights. In order to protect their own political career, the politicians have to shout loudly to be heard of political correctness witch hunt imposed the toxic ideologies and have to strictly implement them in the social governance. The best example is the practice of unisex public toilet that imposed by the people who suffer the inborn defects of hormone disorders to have caused them in uncontrollably seeking homosexuality; which is a antihuman behavior of that boy seeking love with boy, and girls seeking love with girls; in order to get rid of such embarrassment of their shameful behavior; they enforce the hormone normal people to do the same. For which; Germany passed law that helps trans people easily update their legal documents to legalize and easy their illegal play; a German politician in power actually said that "We simply want to make life a bit easier for a small group for which it has great significance." German politicians are the most brainless in the West. Play green card; Chancellor Friedrich Merz destroyed most advanced nuclear power plants, the Ex destroyed the most advanced coal-fired power plant, paid war of Ukraine got return destroyed cheap natural gas pipelines. Reports that many German companies moved headquarters and R&D to China. Aug 13, 2023, article Kemi Badenoch: All buildings must provide single-sex lavatories reports that Ms Badenoch, British Minister for Women and Equalities, stated that the Government must step in when “common sense disappears,” following a rise in businesses offering gender-neutral toilets without separate single-sex facilities. Ms Badenoch argues that the discourse around sex-based rights has been “confused” by gender activists, leading to the necessity for legislation that would not have been required a decade ago. “My job is increasingly spent legislating for common sense and stopping those intent on causing harm.” Ms Badenoch indicates that doctors reported instances where girls in certain schools either contracted infections or skipped classes entirely “because they refused to urinate all day” due to their reluctance to use gender-neutral toilets. What happened in British schools revealed the bad consequence of German politician said that "We simply want to make life a bit easier for a small group for which it has great significance." In comparison with sober Ms Badenoch, the German politician was in doing evil by clear mind that is in helping minority bad to ruin the life of majority good. Sept 9, 2023, in an interview with the Mail, Liz Truss, the former PM of Britain; who slams the idiotically childish play in the democracies, “If you look at the knots in which people tie themselves in western politics about whether somebody with a penis is a man or not, it shows how effective unfortunately these people have been.” In North America, school teachers were not teaching children with knowledge properly, but instead seduce children to undergo permanent gender reassignment. If parents dare to oppose, they will deprive them of their guardianship rights. On June 30, 2020, Abigail Shrier, a doctor of law at Yale Law School, published the book Irreversible Damage: The Transgender Craze Seducing Our Daughters, asking, how did we get to this point? In Washington State, a 13-year-old girl began "gender affirmation" treatment without her parents' consent. In Oregon, a 15-year-old girl underwent a "top surgery" - a double mastectomy - without her parents' permission. The people of China have highest IQ scores globally Just as computer memory stores, the neurons in the human brain, acting as the memory of human intelligence. In China benefit from a good living environment and adequate nutrition, promoted people in neurons healthy development. In contrast, the chaotic life of other countries badly impacted their people in the development of brain cells, so that their IQ scores are lower. Dec. 23, 2011, article Optimal IQ's for Various Groups, BY ROBERT A. LINDSAY, (it has lost link). Average IQ of various countries: China 112-118, Europe 92-102, India 92-96, Africa 85. Below is a map of the average IQ of different races around the world, made by Western enthusiasts. 
Image source: https://www.reddit.com/r/Maps/comments/1garakk/global_iq_map/
Reflecting on man-made tragedies, it is the level of intelligence that determines the behavior of different races: [1] China, purposefully cultures people as quality human, so that it has been world leading economy, explored Silk Road in 2,000 years ago to survive the people in West mutually killings. Now, the Silk Road updated as Belt and Road Initiative, bringing billions of marginalized people into the world economy, raising their lives from $2 to $10-15 per day, making them live in dignity as human. [2] Europe, never cultures people as human, but making feud Gods brainwash people as sworn enemies as beasts in killing from past to this day. It made democracy to grant power to social garbage, it made values, and human rights, using them as excuses to constantly provoke wars. It designed its society as a bullring, and tamed people into bullfighting bulls; and looking for target attacking in parliament, society and world widely, they stirred their own country and the world as boiling pot, bubbling. [3] India, willingly been swept by foreign civilizations several times, it has accumulated all of the garbage of the world's civilizations. Various absurd ideologies and religions are rampant, and it is good at creating more evil local ones. Dehumanized people as animals and recognized cows as ancestors. Bridges built collapsed, Dams built crumbled, and whatever they do has been ruined. [4] Africa has never been properly humanized. Without the wisdom to build a habitable home, it has always been in a semi-cave state. People were captured and sold into slavery to Europe and America. Later, they voluntarily wandered to various parts of the world. Unable to make a living normally, but they are good at crimes and good at makes livings by putting stockings over their heads. The IQ of the above-mentioned countries is only an average. There are people with higher IQs in all of country. Unfortunately, people with low IQs cannot consider the bad consequences. Therefore, they are bold and reckless; and often occupy the leadership positions.
The social significance of the highest IQ scores Sep. 20, 2015, the article Israel to bring in 20,000 Chinese construction workers said that the work-speed of China's worker is 50% higher than that of others. No one will doubt that, if there were no China's workers, there would be no Western and Atlantic Railroad of the United States.
Mar. 31, 2020, Reuters reports From zero to hero: Italy's Chinese help beat coronavirus indicates that in the storm of infection and death sweeping Italy, 50,000 ethnic Chinese who live in the town of Prato were zero infection. In Italy, the most of Chinese people wear masks when they go out since the pandemic started; also other reports said that Chinese people are no longer seen in the public entertainment venues since the start of the pandemic. Please remember, this happened in Italy; a country where was in perfect democratic played governance without the pressure of dictatorship but in the state of freedom of people acting as free as that of herding cats. However, under the environment where the Covid virus is raging and killing people; who want to enjoy freedom, who must be paid the price by own life. Clearly, the highest IQ scores intelligence of Chinese people understood this point. Nov 8, 2021, Montreal Chinese Hospital honoured for pandemic response: In January 2020, two months before Quebec announced its first pandemic lockdown; staff at the Montreal Chinese Hospital were already wearing masks and limiting visitors. Many of the long-term care centre’s employees had also started living separately from their families. They didn’t want to infect their loved ones, but also didn’t want to risk bringing the virus into the centre. In 1950s, at the poorest time that was just ended civil wars and last 100 years of foreign aggression, in Korean War, by poorest weapon; the highest IQ scores intelligence army of China defeated the U.S. led the advance armed United Nations Army of 16 nations to force U.S. humiliatingly signed armistice agreement historically. In 1962, Western countries including United States collectively armed Indian troop to provoke war with China. The troop of China defeated the troop of India as that of the West described as that of driving a herd of Indian buffaloes. Politicians playing human rights destroyed manufacturing Besides the disasters as Professor Herbert Grubel indicated in low quality population replaced; the most fatal one is playing human rights corrupted labor productivity and uprooted foundation for manufacturing. For pleasing voters, politicians advocate human rights to support union culture in regarding that strikes for more by doing less, in unearned gains is in line with human rights; otherwise, it is slave labor and had corrupted the quality of labors, after the left of the WWI and WWII quality generations, the labor productivity had brought away forever, the democracies have lost the ability for manufacturing; the investments wasted in endless strikes, lawsuits and management corruptions. Please look at the shocking reality of Canada's manufacturing declining: Jan. 13, 2012, Canada manufacturing plants disappearing at twice pace of U.S. Oct. 01, 2012, Canada's productivity lags U.S. in 'virtually every instance' Nov. 28, 2012, Ontario's decade-long decline in employment led by factory sector Oct. 31, 2017, Substantial decline in Ontario manufacturing: report Manufacturing The ideologies, such as, values, freedom, human rights, unions; social polarization, their starting points are good, but, the social outcomes are bad. So, I called them as confused ideologies. The cause of Canada's manufacturing decline is nothing else, but the mess in corporate management, since it has been in confused ideologies kidnapping by the brain defectives. Canada once has world class leading manufacturers; but suicidal declined. Nortel Networks was a dominant Canadian telecommunications equipment manufacturer, founded in 1895 as Northern Electric employed 94,000 people globally with groundbreaking inventions; but it filed for bankruptcy in 2009; and was liquidated by 2017, marking one of Canada's biggest corporate failures. Research In Motion - RIM, later renamed as BlackBerry Limited; it was a Canadian software company specializing in cyber-security. Founded in 1984, it originally developed the BlackBerry brand of interactive pagers, smartphone and tablets. In the global smartphone industry, RIM can be called as originator and pioneer; but now, the most of people may don't know it anymore. Bombardier Inc. was founded in 1942; a Canadian aerospace manufacturer which produces business jets. During the 1970s and 1980s, the company diversified into public transport vehicles and commercial jets; and grew particularly fast at the end of the 1980s, and it became a multinational corporation. The deep debts push it to the brink of bankruptcy by 2015. As a result, the company sold nearly all of its operations except business jet manufacturing. Today, in the democracies of the West; much of the infrastructures were the legacy of two generations who suffered the WWI & WWII; the hardships of life during the war cultivated their industrious frugal quality. Please look at the disappointed reports from the leading democracies in the West. Feb 17 2025, Germany: German $11 billion rail disaster: Stuttgart 21 became a never-ending infrastructure nightmare. July 20 2025, Britain; HS2 high-speed railway doomed into mess, say insiders - because of a 'problem in this country'. Today, except China, no country is able to timely-on-budgeted complete the major infrastructure projects. Nowadays, no made in China in daily goods, no one is able to live well. I wrote many topic for resuing the manufatring of Canada 2014, Management is the Art of Playing Human Nature, I indicate that: “Human behaviors determined by dual natures: The cultural nature of acquired altruistic quality, and the natural (animal) nature of inborn selfish instinct. The Management is to finish purposeful tasks with culture nature driven by meeting animal nature with payment under enforcement of regulations. So that management is the Art of playing human natures. Whether the Corporate Culture or the Organizational Culture, they all should be composed of the measures that are able to motivate the maximum exertion of employee’s cultural nature with minimum play of employee’s animal nature to maximize the production efficiency. The success of any enterprise is the result of good played human nature. Successful entrepreneurs are thinkers, philosophers, strategists and so on, who are growing up in the practice and should serve as national policy makers. The failure of Socialist-Bloc is due to it over relied on cultural nature by suppressing the animal nature, while the failure of the Capitalist-Bloc is due to it over relied on animal nature; China is good at the best use of both. Do not simply use so-called morality to cover up human animal nature, do not simply use of so-called value to perform social governance. The US management consultant Peter Drucker said: the purpose of an organization is to make ordinary people do extraordinary things. Management is efficiency; management is profit. 2008,Reducing Psychological Pressure in management and work place. Jan. 8 2008, a report Stress Causes Everything said that “Stress, to put it bluntly, is bad for you. It can kill you, in fact. A study reveals that stress causes deterioration in everything from your gums to your heart and can make you more susceptible to everything from the common cold to cancer. Pathogenic role of stress cannot be changed; however, it can be reduced even avoided. 2014, The Fatal DNA failed RIM & Canadian Enterprises. 12 years ago, in Toronto Canada, I went to make a copy of a key, the man who worked for me was a great aged locals. He sees my key, and then to find the blank key with the same shape of my showing to him. Maybe the great contribution of his great age, after a while, he did not find the proper one in the thousands of hanging blank keys. I felt somewhat anxious and said with finger pointing: “that one should be fine.” He immediately said with unhappy: “do not teach me, this is my business.” His reaction in response of my suggestion is far quick compared with his retarded body movements under serious degraded brain that eroded by time stream naturally, which has engraved unforgettable impression in my mind. That was my first time to taste the taste of the business philosophy of the Canada. It should be a rare wisdom with negative value. It is the one of the most fatal DNA of Canadian enterprises.
2016, How to save Canada’s manufacturing from disappearing.
In the Era of market economy, living space has changed into market space from the geographic space of agricultural economy; the decline of manufacturing industry is in destructing the living space of Canadians. Actually, the democratic politics is the main killer of manufacturing industry by making low quality people in power; those people have no human brain for doing humanized duty; besides eagerly make livings by playing democracy and well feed by people to destroy the life of people. According to 17 years intended work-experienced cases of the closed and out-relocated manufacturers in Canada, this article analyzed the cause of the decline of Canada’s manufacturing industry and discussed the potential measures for reviving it. 2016, How to save Bombardier from the road-dust of failed RIM.
In a long-run enterprise, due to the people are familiar between each other with friendship, the relationships between the managements and staffs are intricate complicated. It is difficult to deal with some problems decisively by the existing managements. It is not due to the ignorance or irresponsibility at all, but, due to the common nature of human beings. The best way is to introduce external powerful leadership with injecting into exotic vibrant DNA. No matter who dealing with the problems in the business, the available solutions will much be same in the major, however, the introduced experts do not have the fetters of the friendship with the existing staff, so that they are less concern when dealing with inevitable personnel issue. More importantly, in this roundabout way, it will be less causing hostility and unrest. The solution is to stop pleasing voter; thereby avoiding advocates human rights. The civilization of China can humanize beast democracy of West
The cause is that democracy makes social garbage in power, such ones eagerly play democracy for enjoying lavish salaries, benefits, and political privileges, but without basic quality that needed to govern a country.
The acceptable way out is to learn Technocratic Democracy of China to form a civil legislature by entreprenurs, scientists, engineers, and so on, part time self reliance work as lawmakers. Then takes 30% vote rights to parallel run with the Gov-one, thereby humanize the beast antihuman democracy.
Everyone has certain intellectual flaw with limitation; only contribution proved social elites are able to make right judgment less mistake.
Also by people respected social elites in part time self reliance work as lawmakers, the formation of civil legislature and its policy will be no one dared oppose; which is the only feasible way that will be widely acceptable.
With the non-partisan advantage; the civil legislature needn’t care about pleasing voters, needn’t care about the political correctness; which is able to get rid of the fatal harm of democratic politics; so that the civil legislature is able to propose some policies that joke politicians dared not proposed.
Cultural & political base of civilization of China lasts 5,000 years
The Confucian collectivist culture and the Imperial Examination chooses learned people in power is the cultural ballast for the civilization of China uninterrupted lasting for 5,000 years. The west takes power as gift for competing and makes beasts in power, the liberal democracy does the same. I remember that I once read an article said that Professor Niall Ferguson once said that Christianity has an impact on the development of Chinese civilization. Here; I would like to indicate that the Christianity has no impact on the development of China, because it is no any force can influence the civilization dominated by Confucianism. Historically, many settled farming civilizations were wiped out by the barbaric nomads. Ancient Egypt, ancient Babylon, ancient India and China are collectively known as the four ancient civilizations; but only the civilization of China has uninterrupted last 5000 of years. The so-called wiped out was the replacement of culture, religions. In China the famous dynasty Qing Dynasty, were basically established by invading nomadic tribes. However, the nomadic tribes cannot carry out cultural replacement due to the existed strong cultural ballast, the social atmosphere of Confucian culture, and the imperial examination system selecting talents from outside of the royal bloodline govern the country. So that the invading nomadic tribes have to continue to respect Confucianism as moral guidance, and continue to take the Imperial Examination to select learned talents out of the royal to rule the country. They also used barbaric nature to expand territory to strengthen the civilization of China.
There is a English word Sinofication that made by Westerner; it is exactly true. In history, many invading nations and cultures integrated into the civilization of China, and contributed to the culture and nation of China. The West making cultural replacement started in 1400s, missionaries endlessly entered China; but they cannot move the cultural ballast. For brainwashing people of China, they cut off the culture of China and forbid believers to worship own ancestors and Confucius, believers angered burned down churches and beat missionaries away. Later, the Pope has to grant special approval to allow worship of ancestors and Confucius. However, the culture replacement that was successful in other countries failed in China. The West has never humanized in ruining the life of world people.
Faced with democracy makes beast in power ruined world; we must explore way to self rescue, instead of passively waiting to be finished. Whether you like it or not, China is humanizng the West dehumanized world, which is not through military conquer, but through humanized culture. A life human or inhuman depends on cultured people human or inhuman. China develops ritual and Confucian cultures people as quality human in collective self discipline and do not do to others what you would not have them do to you; in collectivist values & peace seeking genes, which created Eastern collectivist civilization with social elements suitable for human survival. The West fabricates Gods brainwashing people as sworn enemies to hatred kill each other and regarding that loot-kills others for being No.1 as a matter of course; in individualist values & war seeking genes; which made Western individualist civilization with social elements destructing human survival. The inhuman genes inherited into everything in the West to ruin human life. The purpose of establishing a government in human society is for using the administrative power of the government to suppress the wrongful behaviors of the low quality people to create a livable society. But the democratic design made the government as the drama stage for the reckless play of the low quality people. Multiparty political design hopes that multiparty opposition can ensure a quality government; but human selfish instinct made the multiparty opposition as maliciously opposition; for replacing the ruling position to enjoy self given luxury salaries, benefits and privileges in regardless ruining the life of own families. Please look at the thoughtful names for making livings by play democracy: Hawks, Dovish, Donkey, Elephant, Left wing, Right wing, Extreme right, Extreme left, Green Party, Tea party, Liberal party, Conservative Party, Democratic Party... No one will believe people in such quality are able to make rational policies. Human suffered tragedies were from mess in governance of the values & human rights hijacking created free world in chaotic state without restraint; all kinds of evil are free prevailing. Antihuman democracy makes power to antihuman beasts; and then they abuse the power antihumanly destructing human life. Canada PM Mark Carney declared the end of U.S. hegemony Since Columbus's voyage to discover the New World, European powers colluded to form an Evil Axis, looting, killing, colonizing the world. During World War II, the U.S. took over continued to plunder world bombing the world.
For a long time, politicians globally yielded to the evil manner of the U.S.; but in the speech at Davos 2026, Dr. Mark Carney declared the Dawn of New Era to alarm for the end of U.S. hegemony that by milittary plunders and economic blackmails the world countries, and sparked global resonance and action. Previously, globally politicians succumbed to the U.S. blackmail because their small economic size & lack of military capability. Now, re-rised China; in economic size and military strength are formidable, and wise PM Mark Carney cooperates with China and also uniting with the numerous other countries. April 26, 2026 video Mark Carney’s 9-minute walkout just changed global power Forever. After read the 61 pages of blackmail document of U.S., PM Mark Carbey says nothing walking out, and left the US officials astonished. The U.S. stipulates that all Canadian policy-making must be approved by the U.S., manufacturing must be immediately relocated back to the U.S., and raw material prices in Canada must be set by the U.S., Canada must immediately eliminate tariffs on US tariffs, and US tariffs on Canada will be phased out gradually.
On May 8, 2026 video, Canada terminated all trade with the United States – a shocking alliance of 14 countries was launched. A comment: I lived in Albany, New York for almost six months, and almost all the agricultural products in the supermarkets were from Canada. They were of good quality and inexpensive. Americans are very lazy and don't grow vegetables, so it's natural for them to buy everything from Canada. Today, Trump's move against Canada only hurts Americans; it won't harm Canada. It's incredibly stupid. The action of PM Mark Carney was not only won the praise of people all over the world, but also provided the courage and model for others follow. Below was the email I sent to Prof. Herbert Grubel.
Hongde Li May 2, 2026 17:03
收件人：herbert.grubel@shaw.ca, Mark.carney@parl.gc.ca, pm@pm.gc.ca, goldy.hyder@thebusinesscouncil.ca, vieprivee@quebecor.com, social.media@bombardier.com, eric.martel@aero.bombardier.com, bdemosky@gmail.com, bart.demosky@earth-front.com, stephen.mccullough@bombardier.com, David.Murray@aero.bombardier.com, Hongde Li The ways rescue democracy ruined Canada PM Mark Carney and Goldy Hyder are rare rational, I hope Prof. Herbert G. Grubel may help them rescue democracy ruined Canada
To Prof. Herbert G. Grubel
Professor of Economics, Simon Fraser Universuty herbert.grubel@shaw.ca Dear Herbert Gunter Grubel This is Frank Li from the city of Waterloo, a Metallographist from P.R. China. This email inspired by interview I cry for you, Canada: 92-year-old prof and ex-MP’s warning about immigration & welfare state. Preaching is useless, please take action and make phone calls by your influence in the political and alchemical circle of Canada . I attach an article Humanize the West dehumanized world, please call PM Mark Carney, Goldy Hyder, CEO, Business Council of Canada. They are rational and have the quality and ability to rescue Canada by promoting acceptable approaches in Canada where people have freedom dehumanized mindlessly to fight against everything. 1...Humanize Democracy Learn to Technocratic Democracy of China to promote form a civil legislature by you and Goldy Hyder by organizing entreprenurs, scientists, engineerd, and social elites from whole Canada in self reliance part time work as lawmakers. Takes 30% vote rights to parallel run with the Govb-one, thereby humanize the beast antihuman democracy. 2...Humanize Healthcare Promote the use of vinegar + melatonin to uproot the dilemma in Universal Healthcare of Canada Vinegar can destruct covalent bonded viruses to uproot infectious disease; and makes physiological indicators normal. Melatonin regenerating cells of nerve, immune, kidney failure restore systems. My experience; water diluting 5% vinegar x 18ml (0.9g pure)/50 kg or 2x500mg vinegar capsules/50kg is able to cure or prevent any cause of fever and coughs of flu; and add melatonin 10 mg is able to cure diabetes, Alzheimer's etc. to uproot the inhuman mind of incurable diseases from western medicine. I took vinegar + melatonin daily once; in days; my vision shockingly improved and I have to dump 200 degree reading glass; because the glass makes my vision blurry, in weeks; my facial skin rosy and smooth, lesser wrinkles, and the digestion, energy, hearing, memory, and mental agility, etc., all improved; show the younger in blood, vessels, microcirculation, and more; systemic rejuvenation in 30 years younger. Vinegar + melatonin will be able to empty emergency rooms and hospitals. By diet supplements self help cure diseases to reduce reliance on public healthcare is the only way to stop the killing of Western medicine. Please try the suggested dose; you will be shocked by amazing systemic rejuvenation in 30 years younger. Then suggests to friends and Professors. <<<<<<<<<<>>>>>>>>>>>> Dr. Mark Carney is the designer of the 21st century. Since Columbus's voyage to discover the New World, European powers colluded to form an Evil Axis, plundering and killing people all over the world. During World War II, the US took over continued to plunder and bomb the world. For a long time, politicians around the world yielded to evil manners; but Dr. Mark Carney sounded the alarm for the end of the world by American hegemony that bombs the world by plundering the world, and sparked global action. See April 26, 2026 video Mark Carney’s 9-Minute Walkout Just Changed Global Power Forever. He rejected the coercion from U.S. politicians. Please Google Dr. Mark Carney in education & profession background, especially since taking office of Gov-Canada, he has made speeches and policies; we may conclude that in the current world he is a rare sober politician. I believe that Dr. Mark Carney is the leader for the new world in action; his thoughts and brave actions ushered in and re-defined the humanized development of the 21st century and made human beings live a life as human should. In comparison, many politicians are in the quality of street girls or boys and eagerly playing democracy for enjoying lavish salaries and benefits, and political privileges, but without basic qualities that are needed to govern a country. Below is a section of my new writing, to help understand the fact why Canada was dehumanized unlivable. Recently I happily read a post of Dr. Jostein Hauge: “China has done so much more for global prosperity than the West, I'm shocked at how blatantly accepted it's become to hold anti-China views in the West.” The answer is simple, the West has never humanized; people view inhuman as humane. Here are the distinction of the civilization of China is human, the West is beast inhumane. To govern the remote areas where riots broke out; the royal power had to send family members to remote areas with lands as vassal states independent economy war machines; 771BC China fell into 550 years of wars. The disasters of wars enlightened that ideology used for rumor making wars and brainwashing people as War maniacs. So that in 134BC, China had to outlaw schools of thought. China has been taking lessons to avoid repeating the mistakes, but in the West; Hegel indicated: “What experience and history teach is this, that peoples and governments have never learned anything from history, and have never acted on the lessons that should have been learned from it”. The antihuman west made God-religions brainwash people as sworn enemies to have torn apart humanity and culture and to have hatred fragmented the world in economy and society. The belief of China is Confucian self-collective discipline; do not do others what you would not have them do to you. But the belief of the West is fabricated God to kill for the sake of God. This was the reason that Zheng He Fleet (1405-1433) 7 times around the world, besides fair trade, did not make colonial rule; and presented large numbers of books to the Italian pope to trigger the West out of the Dark Ages. But 59 years later Columbus discovered the New World, The West swarming out to kill, loot, and colonize the world. Today, Britain still preserved over 20,000 cultural relics of China. In the West; until this moment, it has never control the ideology; so that the antihuman culture cultured antihuman people by their antihuman brains endlessly fabricate antihuman ideologies; by which endlessly plants the antihuman cultural landmines and evil bombing human world. The most beast antihuman cultural landmines are democracy and human rights; democracy makes beasts in power; while human rights protect criminal crimes. Now let alone wars, in democracies; people lost basic sense of security in home. In Canada, police advises people leave car key outside to avoid robbery hurting people; if you fight with robbery, will be jailed due to violent human rights. The human rights protect union culture regarding strike for more by doing less in unearned gains as in line with human rights; otherwise it is slave labor in violating human rights; and corrupted quality of labor, the left of WWII hard life cultured quality generation, the labor productivity brought away forever. The democracies in West; have been human rights uprooted foundation for manufacturing. The West made everything in the perfect antihuman ensure killing human life. The antihuman West cultures antihuman beasts promote the antihuman stuff by Color Revolution & war. Internationally; look at the bloody war killing, it is the antihuman politicians driving State Apparatus to force people kill or be killed. Domestically; Britain & son Canada are ongoing a population shift that high quality elites flee and replaced by low quality people. The countries have plagued in the mess and poverty in semi-cave proved the low quality of its people, who cannot be trained to be law-abiding citizens or qualified constructors, but skilled destructors. Britain is filling in such waste trash. The government spends huge sums of money to feed and attract illegal immigrants by providing them with hotels; while own citizens poor sleep on the streets; crimes are rampant and led to its citizens lost dignity as a human should be. Such manmade antihuman disasters rooted into the tomb of the ancestors of Briton. Briton’s proud of ancestors made proud of representative democracy has been destructing the world and uprooting the base for the survival of their own descendants and the life of world people by making beasts and psychos in power. Dr. Jostein Hauge should re-examine the performance of own intelligence; If merely keens on preaching; no action to stop disaster. Look at Professor Jeffrey Sachs, Diplomat Kishore Mahbubani, etc., for years they exhausted preaching; but the democracy makes beasts in power ruining world into extinction; due to they didn’t take action to fix the democracy beast play. People around the world are desperately seeking a way to survive; they all understand and thank the sincerity of Professor Jeffrey Sachs, Diplomat Kishore Mahbubani; etc.; but their preaching cannot rescue humans from ruined. Here are my explored feasible approaches for Dr. Jostein Hauge solving the real problems in Britain. Sincerely Frank Li, May 2, 2026
Shared to
Mark.carney@parl.gc.ca, pm@pm.gc.ca, Media@pmo-cpm.gc.ca Goldy Hyder, CEO, Business Council of Canada:
goldy.hyder@thebusinesscouncil.ca Pierre Karl Péladeau, President, Quebecor Inc: vieprivee@quebecor.com Herbert Grubel : herbert.grubel@shaw.ca Bombardier éric Martel, President and CEO: social.media@bombardier.com, eric.martel@aero.bombardier.com Bart Demosky, Vice President CEO: bdemosky@gmail.com, bart.demosky@earth-front.com Stephen Mccullough, Executive Engineering: stephen.mccullough@bombardier.com David Murray, Executive Manufacturing, IT: David.Murray@aero.bombardier.com Gmail - Humanize the West dehumanized world 291K 1... Canada should not open its doors to the world
Herbert Grubel Oct 1, 2015 https://nationalpost.com/opinion/herbert-grubel-canada-should-not-open-its-doors-to-the-world An influx of new immigrants could bankrupt our welfare state The refugee crisis in Europe has prompted many Canadians to demand that the government admit large numbers of refugees for permanent resettlement. Most of these demands are motivated by humanitarian sentiments but they are also supported by libertarians who argue for unlimited immigration on the grounds that it would benefit all Canadians, just like it has in the past, creating a country of social harmony, high incomes and a quality of life that is one of the best in the world. The Post's Terence Corcoran recently made this argument (‘Open our doors to the world,’ Sept. 11). However, the libertarian analysis is no longer valid in today’s world. First, there is no more fertile empty land on the prairies that requires immigrants to cultivate. In fact, technology used by farmers now is so efficient and labour-saving that people are leaving the land to settle in towns and cities. Second, the cost and risk of travel are so much lower, while the pool of potential immigrants and the economic gains they can expect are so much larger than ever before in Canada’s history, meaning that an open border would result in a tsunami of immigrants. Third, immigrants would no longer come from Europe, where populations are declining, but from Asia, Africa and Latin America. The cultures and values of these regions are much different, especially with regard to religious tolerance and the treatment of women and people with different sexual orientations. In spite of the official policy of multiculturalism, these backgrounds are likely to delay integration into Canadian society and if the migrants are numerous enough, may well end up creating ethnic enclaves in which the occupants’ culture and religions are maintained. Such enclaves can lead to economic, social and political frictions. France, the Netherlands, Austria, Sweden and other Western democracies have such problems, which have led to the electoral success of anti-immigrant parties and further social tensions. Fourth, many immigrants will be Muslims. Most of them are peaceful and tolerant, but an unknown, potentially large number will be militant jihadists and present a serious threat to Canadian security. Surveillance of this minority will be very costly and cannot prevent all risks. No such problems and costs have ever accompanied immigration before. Fifth, the most important difference between modern Canada and when previous waves of immigrants entered this country is the existence of the welfare state. In the absence of its universal social benefits in the past, only healthy immigrants with strong work ethics, drive and skills came to Canada. Under present conditions, potentially many immigrants would not possess these qualities and impose heavy fiscal burdens on our welfare programs and ultimately bankrupt them. It is for this reason that Milton Friedman, one of the world’s most ardent advocates for human and economic freedom concluded that, “The welfare state and free immigration are incompatible.” The problem identified by Friedman has been quantified in a study by myself and Patrick Grady, in which we found that the average incomes and tax payments of recent immigrants (documented by Statistics Canada) are much lower than those of the average Canadian and that the immigrants consume roughly the same amount of government services as the average Canadian. The difference between the taxes paid and services consumed by the average recent immigrant equals about $6,000 annually. Given the total number of these immigrants, the annual fiscal burden on Canadian taxpayers comes to about $30 billion. Sixth, immigrants in large numbers cause a substantial redistribution of income, decreasing the incomes of workers and increasing the income of employers. Drawing on the basic results of a study of the redistribution effect in the United States by Harvard University Professor of Economics George Borjas, in Canada the decrease of the annual income of labour is $40 billion and the gain of employers is $43.5 billion, resulting in a net gain of $3.5 billion for the latter. This gain is called the immigration effect and is due to increased opportunities to trade. Advocates for free immigration make much of this gain but the data show that it is very small relative to the redistribution of income. These advocates also laud the increase in Canada’s aggregate national income resulting from the immigrants’ economic activities. However, all of this increase accrues to the immigrants in the form of wages, lowers per capita incomes and is accompanied by greater congestion and pollution in metropolitan areas. Increased demand for and cost of housing reduces the ability of young Canadians to own homes and start families, creating frictions between generations. The economic and social costs just discussed do not make the case against all immigration but make the case for the selection of immigrants with prospects for economic success that are high enough to eliminate the fiscal burden and the admission of immigrants in numbers small enough to prevent the risk of creating the substantial redistribution of income, the establishment of ethnic enclaves, the threat of jihadist terror and the problems associated with substantial and rapid population increases. In the context of the current debate over policies for the admission of refugees from the Middle East, it is important for all Canadians that these considerations are given proper weight in the selection of immigrants and decisions about their numbers.
2...Carney's Diplomacy for a Changed World: 'Cometh the Hour, Cometh the Man'This piece is part of our Policy Series: Carney's Canada One Year Later. By Jeremy Kinsman April 20, 2026 https://www.policymagazine.ca/carneys-diplomacy-for-a-changed-world-cometh-the-hour-cometh-the-man/?  Prime Minister Mark Carney at the Kananaskis G7 in June, 2025/PMO
Mark Carney is the first prime minister of Canada thrust into office by an external threat. Donald Trump’s repeated threats to annex Canada left Canadians disbelieving, outraged, and then very apprehensive. Weary of Justin Trudeau after a decade, they knew that a feminist foreign policy wasn’t going to counter the predatory and destructive impulses of the monster next door. “There are some who say there’s no need for a comprehensive plan,” Carney said on April 19th in the first of what will be regular addresses branded Forward Guidance. “They believe we should wait it out in the hope that the United States will return to normal, that the good old days will come back.” “But hope isn’t a plan, and nostalgia is not a strategy.” When desperate Liberals turned massively to Carney — an internationally respected private financier and sought-after central banker — to replace Trudeau, some pundits doubted that he had the political chops. But as a freshman retail politician, Carney came across as thoughtful, substantive, likeably natural, authentic as a Canadian, and an escape from the deluge of empty talking points in which our political discourse had become lost. Most of all, he convinced anxious Liberals and then Canadian voters that he knew where and how to lead us in our urgently needed national defence. Carney’s week-by-week surge in the 2025 election campaign drew, for a Canadian, unprecedented attention in Europe and elsewhere. The former governor of the Bank of England’s record of competence in managing crises and obtaining stability was repeatedly recalled in the European press. His election win in Canada and the resurrection of the Liberals resonated in the democratic world as a reason to believe moderate, centrist politics could still appeal. But the crucial story-making cachet appealing to Trump-shaken Canadian partners was that of a respected democracy’s front-line resistance to bullying and threats from the rampaging U.S. president. “We are all Canadians now,” wrote Bill Emmott, former editor of The Economist, in his old magazine. He didn’t defend Canada from Trump’s threats and tariff coercion by pleading for a less-bad tariff deal from the U.S., hoping to buy predictability from a protection racket.
Building on the value of our unique expertise as a front-line target of Trump’s predation both economic and military, Carney embarked on a mission of consolidating countervailing power among rational, rule-of-law observing geopolitical partners. As a result, over the past year, Mark Carney has become the face of Canada abroad, identified with both competence and security. He didn’t defend Canada from Trump’s threats and tariff coercion by pleading for a less-bad tariff deal from the U.S., hoping to buy predictability from a protection racket. In his landmark speech at Davos, Carney declared that our longstanding “normal” was now irreparably ruptured by the U.S. under Trump; the postwar multilateral system of international rules, norms, and institutions created to govern trade, commerce, peace and security, and almost everything else was now shredded. Carney has harnessed that crisis as the opportunity for Canadians to engage in a generational effort to strengthen national capabilities at home, while partnering more deeply and widely abroad. Carney’s frame for this imperative is his oracular assessment of the need to build middle-power coalitions of the willing to ensure that a cooperative world order survives America’s defection to the one dominated by predatory hegemons. The Prime Minister is propelling a startling invigoration of foreign policy, forming a triad of transformative building at home, the recalibration of partnerships abroad, and globally, diplomatic stimulus to rebuild productive multilateral cooperation, along with specific subsets, such as reinvesting and revitalizing the military, and protecting and nurturing the Arctic. In his keynote speech to the Liberal convention on April 11, Carney recalled Louis St. Laurent ‘s contribution as Foreign Affairs minister and prime minister. In 1947, St. Laurent laid out the principles of postwar Canadian foreign policy: to secure national unity, manage relations with the United States, and pursue “humanistic” purposes in the world, by providing “economic and moral force” to less fortunate nations of the emerging Global South. Obviously, Carney intends Canada to prioritize management of relations with the U.S. as beneficially as possible, while trying to reduce our vulnerability and over-dependence. As to St. Laurent’s promise of a “humanistic” global outlook, Carney is almost silent on Canadian commitment to urgencies of humanitarian assistance, and the enduring need of developmental aid, especially on climate-change mitigation, which seems to be paling as a policy priority.  Mark Carney greeting Volodymyr Zelensky at the Kananaskis G7 in June, 2025/PMO
He has mightily increased spending on military defence while cutting the budget for development spending and Global Affairs Canada, limiting our soft-power branding abroad. Carney has, however, spoken out after attacks on Iran (controversially, via a rolling response) and Lebanon, and the on the handling of Gaza, and of the need to respect international law, prompting rebuke from the Israeli government, with which bilateral relations have eroded. Carney’s diplomatic agenda was evident when, after being sworn in as PM last March, he went immediately to London and Paris. The month before, desperate to curry Trump’s favour amid an unjust tariff war, Keir Starmer had, during his Oval Office crucible, plucked from his breast pocket an invitation by King Charles for a second state visit by the anglophile American president. In-between Starmer’s Trump bilateral and the president’s visit to London last September, Charles made his status as the only non-resident head of state with any role to play in Canada indisputably clear by delivering the Speech from the Throne in Ottawa at the end of May. He was greeted by Canadians with a euphoria unrivalled since his mother’s first visit as monarch in 1957. It seems improbable that Carney and King Charles, whose paths of course crossed during the former’s seven years at the Bank of England, would not have acknowledged informally to each other the probability that Donald Trump had no idea when threatening to annex Canada that Charles is Canada’s head of state. After the powerful May tutorial on that technicality, the King no doubt mentioned it during Trump’s September audience. The visit to Macron, to whom Carney had been an informal economic adviser, had historical resonance, but also cemented an alliance of minds on our geopolitical dislocation. After a year of record-breaking prime ministerial travel that might be dubbed “variable-geometry diplomacy”, Carney has begun boasting of “20 new security partnerships on four continents.” One year into Carney’s deft navigation of a new geopolitical status quo, partners abroad increasingly perceive Canada quite favourably as “‘he other North America’.
His diplomatic strategy and style reflect the leveraging of that bold-face global speed-dial list he accrued over 12 years as a central banker, including three as chair of the post-2008 Financial Stability Board, combined with the force multiplier of the Davos speech. It is increasingly evident that under Donald Trump, the United States has adopted the hegemonic default posture that prioritizes its own sovereignty above all, while discounting the sovereignty of other nations. Trump recognizes no constraints on unilateral U.S. action based on international law, behavioural convention or moral code . Carney has emerged as a tribune for the opposing worldview that respects international norms and laws, while managing nonetheless a working relationship with the U.S. president, as we head into decisive CUSMA renewal negotiations, which the US seems to want to kick down the road. In the meantime, Canada is bonding with President Claudia Sheinbaum and Mexico. “Canada is the most European of non-European nations,” Carney has quipped, and Europe is targeted as a key partner in the transformation of our economy “from one that is reliant on a single trade partner to one that is stronger, more self-sufficient, and resilient to global shocks.” Canada has worked to cement privileged relations with Europe for more than half a century. We agreed an enhanced and updated Strategic Partnership Agreement last June, and enjoy a far-reaching Comprehensive Economic and Trade Agreement (CETA). Our commitment to join Europeans in the coalition of the willing to defend and help rebuild Ukraine reinforces Canada’s trans-Atlantic solidarity. Europe is a natural, comprehensively compatible partner because of NATO links, and values convergence. Carney’s foreign itinerary in year one reflected our particular compatibility with Nordic countries, in-built partners for Arctic development and protection. Recently, polls have shown majority support among Canadians for exploring the once-fanciful notion of Canada joining the EU. Carney has also positioned Canada’s presence more firmly in Indo-Pacific networks, making bilateral visits to Beijing, Delhi, Tokyo, and Singapore, and attending the ASEAN summit in Kuala Lumpur, and the APEC Summit in Seoul. Carney’s visits to China and to India re-set pragmatic relations on a positive track with these economic and geopolitical heavyweights after the bilateral dislocations of the last decade. One year into Carney’s deft navigation of a new geopolitical status quo, partners abroad increasingly perceive Canada quite favourably as “the other North America,” seeking beneficial common ground. Mark Carney has described clearly what has to be done at this generational junction in world affairs and national interests. Getting it done relies on both our transformative capacities at home, and our diplomatic reach abroad. Policy Columnist Jeremy Kinsman served as Canada’s ambassador to Russia, high commissioner to the UK, ambassador to Italy and ambassador to the European Union. He is a Distinguished Fellow of the Canadian International Council.
|
