设万维读者为首页 万维读者网 -- 全球华人的精神家园 广告服务 联系我们 关于万维
 
首  页 新  闻 视  频 博  客 论  坛 分类广告 购  物
搜索>> 发表日志 控制面板 个人相册 给我留言
帮助 退出
     
  hare的博客
  In Reason We Trust
网络日志正文
与德国哲学教授关于中国是否有哲学的对话 2015-06-12 17:03:01

以下是我与德国在台湾讲学的教授,关于中国哲学的对话。因为没有征求本人同意,所以如有错误我负责修改。


谢谢

================================== 

博士先生,

 

我...注意到您是哲学系的教授,猜想您也许会中文,所以不揣冒昧寄给您我的书《论范例》的电子版,希望能听到您的评论。

 

很感谢花费了您的时间,

 

致礼!

 

W

FYI:

 

http://www.amazon.com/dp/151162101X/ref=dra_a_rv_mr_ho_it_P320_100?tag=dradisplay-20&ascsubtag=061ffbbb99960b02d640b23d5d87a4f3_S

 

-------------------------

Thank you for sending me your work.
I am afraid my reading ability of Chinese is rather limited. So I cannot appreciate your work. Sorry.
Best,
C. W

Prof. Dr. Dr. C H W
Homepage with CV and publications:
http://sites.google.com/site/wenzelchristian1/


Dear Prof. C,

 

Thank you for letting me know. 

 

I am looking for an translation of my book into German. I wonder if you are interested in working together with me for the purpose? 

 

I still hold the ancient Greek's belief that philosopher's only meaningful life is to seek truth, nothing but the truth, as Socrates, Plato and Aristotle did 2500 years ago and nowadays, I know,  very few philosophers are willing to go that far.

 

I wish you all the best.

 

W

Yes, I also go for truth and beauty in life, and yes, that is what philosophers should do.
I am too much occupied to help you translate your book into German. Sorry. Maybe I will see you some time in Taiwan or at some conference?


C


I would like to go to Taiwan to talk about my new system of philosophy if invited. The problem with Chinese philosophers are that they feel ashamed to admit that they don't understand something as you do. It is their culture nobody can break the boundary even if for philosophers.


W


You are perfectly right. I have that problem with most Taiwanese philosopher professors that I have met. It is difficult for me to have a meaningful philosophical conversation with them. It is a mix of shyness and fear of losing face (and maybe even arrogance?). They are friendly on the surface, but in the end it is frustrating.

Is it better in Mainland China?  I believe it is. But I am not sure

Best,
C

Chinese so called "philosophers" are the same everywhere as you encountered, in the mainland it is even worse, trust me, since I had been one of them for 9 years before I went to America. They never understand what Socrates said "The only thing I know is that I know nothing". My belief is that there is even no "philosopher" today, in any western sense of the word, philosophy, What China has in its so-called 5 thousand years of history is only "thinkers", but, NOT philosophers. In the last 200 years since Chinese came to face westerns unwillingly of course, till now, nobody, absolute nobody, understands the western philosophy systematically - somebody might know 1 or 2 western philosophers at most, It is a big topic - when you have understood the Chinese as well as I do, you would become the world No. 1 汉学家 in the west, can you imagine? no kidding.

 

W

 

I drafted an Abstract for the book you might be interested. 

 

Thanks,

 

W

 

==========================

Abstract for the book "Instancology“

 

“Instancology” is an author-coined word for the name of this new philosophy system on "The Study of the Instance and The Absolute.

 

The purpose of writing this book is to reveal: the final truth on the reality of our world- instead of 2500 years of searching for the fundamental existence or the Being of our world, it is the "Movement" itself, caused by the Absolute - which leads to forming our present, abstract (e.g. existence of Plato's Form or mathematics) AND material worlds.

 

Along this revelation, this dissertation tries to answer questions like "What is Heidegger's Part II (which he could not complete) of his book "The Being and Time", Is mathematics real? Is Plato's Form real? On the argument "What is the reality?", who is correct? Plato or Aristotle? After all, the 4 fundamental questions raised when philosophy in its infantile since ancient Greeks asked: Who am I? Where am I? What is my world? and How should I conduct myself?

 

The method used in developing this system is a new epistemology called "Pure Wu-Xing "(similar to the instance, e.g. when Archimedes shouted "Eureka! ") which explains the  mechanism for creativity and discovery, and which cannot be explained by analysis, reason, rational, logic etc. alone, in the past history of epistemological development in philosophy.

 

By using this new "Pure Wu-Xing", thinking studies thoughts and thoughts reflected on thinking - so on and so forth, each pushes other in turn to higher and higher circle upwards, eventually come to the Absolute, which is the final end of all rational: the truth of reality. It reveals that the nature of thinking is the Absolute also. And relating thinking to the Absolute in the outside world, the two Absolutes are identical. Along this line of logic, this system also throws new lights on the nature of language, Artificial Intelligence ethics and Chinese culture in general and reached its own new conclusions for each field.

 

Your project and vision reminds me of Hegel and his idea of the absolute. Don't you think so, too?
You also talk about Plato and mathematics. I will give a talk tomorrow about mathematics as art:
http://www.kunsthochschulekassel.de/willkommen/veranstaltungen/events/event/mathematik-als-kunst.html

I do not know Chinese well enough to have had the chance to appreciate the literature produced by Chinese "thinkers" (as you prefer to call them). But what I have learned has disappointed me so far. There certainly are some smart people and there is some insight. But is there any systematic philosophy in China? I did not see any so far. I doubt there is. Here is my argument: In philosophy departments today they read the classics that were written 2000 years ago and more. But where, I ask, is the development? No progress since then? Something is missing. Something is wrong.

C

Thanks for the info on your lecture (I don't know German well enough to translated it into English). You are absolutely right on your conclusion that there is no development of philosophy in the last 200 years since the Chinese came to know the west. A bit of development, if any, on the Chinese classical thoughts (I wouldn't call it philosophy in any western sense of the word philosophy). As to your question of what I talked about the Absolute and what Hegel's talk on the absolute. The difference is that Hegel's all-enclosing concept is "Spirit", or "Concept", or "Idea" (you know the original text better than I do I assume). He uses the word "absolute" to MODIFY that concept, but NOT the Absolute itself, similar to Heidegger using the absolute modifying Being as "Da-sein" in translation. So for Hegel, the core concept is the Absolute Spirit and for Heidegger, the Absolute Being, and for me (here you see new development as a Chinese in origin ), the Absolute itself in short.

 

If you'd like to know more I will explain more, I won't disappoint you I promise in my system at least.

 

W

(The End)

浏览(806) (0) 评论(0)
发表评论
我的名片
hare
注册日期: 2012-01-13
访问总量: 2,095,766 次
点击查看我的个人资料
Calendar
最新发布
· 为什么只可以复制生命而无法制造
· 论“无”和范畴重析
· 哲学的开端应该是“虚无”
· 《范例II》目录
· 中国文化思想方面的二个缺陷
· 我被美国的官僚主义报复老实了
· 历史上一流的哲学家为什么没有神
友好链接
· 天蓉:天蓉的博客
· Rabbit:Stinger 的博客
· bunny2:bunny2的博客
· microsoftbug:microsoftbug的博
· InstanceTV:InstanceTV的博客
· 中国现代哲学家学会:中国现代哲
· Madhatter:English_only的博客
分类目录
【公告】
· 川小子承认输了,“但你等着,我
· 他们能算中国人吗?
· 对待文化和语言就应像对待手机
· 关于“范例哲学”的声明
· 支持发展哲学建个人音乐网页
· 《论范例》第一版出版日期:2013
· 【论范例】建议网名改真名通知
· 【】范例电视台本周末讲座预告【
· 关于“范例电视台”的几点说明
· 关于讲座提问的几个事项
【政治】
· 中国文化思想方面的二个缺陷
· 习近平“全面放开外资准入政策”救
· 大陆民众心态和状况的“三个阶段”
· 中国大陆的政治前途:学朝鲜还是
· 为什么在中国,西方的“极端思维”
· 学朝鲜还是学美国 – 中国正被逻
· 习近平会不会杀许家印?
· 中国的经济失落会导致共产党垮台
· 中国的一切问题的根源-中国文化
· 现代中国公民诉求(一号)
【知识分子】
· 欲望与语言教学
· 《常数》的哲学意义
· 什么是“西盲”?
· “中国思维“的十大特点
· 关于形式逻辑和辩证逻辑的笔记
· RAN方法循环示意图(Edited)
· 中国人能不能创造世界一流的成就
· 人的错误观念是如何形成的
· 从秦刚大使的英语口语看英语教学
· “记录历史我们不做谁做”- 胡杰
【生活】
· 我被美国的官僚主义报复老实了
· 历史上一流的哲学家为什么没有神
· 风暴开始了,赶快告诉大陆家人
· 漂亮!
· “2222”- 谁比我更可爱?
· “洋丢人”- 骗骗老外而已
· 谈谈“抽象”与“应用”的关系
· "Proud Boys"翻译为"自信小伙子"
· I cannot remember my mother by
· 俄军又损一将!
【Test】
· 中国的读书人- 政治盲人
· 学外语前个人的语言天赋量化测定
· U r invited to give your BEST
· 2020年美国大选最大的贼-川普本
· 周末思绪
· 海外华人里谁的英语最牛(3)
【绝学】
· 为什么只可以复制生命而无法制造
· 论“无”和范畴重析
· 哲学的开端应该是“虚无”
· 《范例II》目录
· 关于物质的问题(补充)
· 关于物质的问题
· 哲学的属性
· 对“绝对”五条公理的解释(6)
· 现象学与范例的相对范畴
· 三者的本质:时间空间和数字
存档目录
2023-12-20 - 2023-12-24
2023-11-08 - 2023-11-29
2023-10-01 - 2023-10-20
2023-09-03 - 2023-09-19
2023-03-21 - 2023-03-21
2023-01-07 - 2023-01-22
2022-12-04 - 2022-12-04
2022-11-27 - 2022-11-28
2022-09-11 - 2022-09-11
2022-08-07 - 2022-08-07
2022-07-11 - 2022-07-25
2022-06-01 - 2022-06-07
2022-05-05 - 2022-05-29
2022-04-01 - 2022-04-26
2022-03-02 - 2022-03-30
2022-02-12 - 2022-02-28
2022-01-02 - 2022-01-22
2021-12-01 - 2021-12-30
2021-11-03 - 2021-11-27
2021-10-01 - 2021-10-23
2021-09-11 - 2021-09-30
2021-08-05 - 2021-08-22
2021-07-04 - 2021-07-31
2021-05-09 - 2021-05-17
2021-04-18 - 2021-04-18
2021-02-01 - 2021-02-13
2021-01-04 - 2021-01-22
2020-12-17 - 2020-12-17
2020-11-09 - 2020-11-29
2020-10-23 - 2020-10-24
2020-03-21 - 2020-03-21
2020-01-19 - 2020-01-25
2019-08-04 - 2019-08-21
2019-07-04 - 2019-07-05
2019-06-28 - 2019-06-28
2019-05-14 - 2019-05-27
2019-04-06 - 2019-04-26
2019-03-03 - 2019-03-29
2019-02-02 - 2019-02-26
2019-01-01 - 2019-01-31
2018-12-02 - 2018-12-31
2018-11-02 - 2018-11-29
2018-10-01 - 2018-10-26
2018-09-02 - 2018-09-27
2018-08-01 - 2018-08-31
2018-07-01 - 2018-07-31
2018-06-02 - 2018-06-29
2018-05-01 - 2018-05-27
2018-04-05 - 2018-04-25
2018-03-01 - 2018-03-30
2018-02-06 - 2018-02-25
2018-01-06 - 2018-01-31
2017-12-01 - 2017-12-31
2017-11-04 - 2017-11-26
2017-10-27 - 2017-10-27
2017-08-25 - 2017-08-31
2017-07-11 - 2017-07-15
2017-04-02 - 2017-04-25
2017-01-18 - 2017-01-18
2016-11-15 - 2016-11-15
2016-04-04 - 2016-04-11
2016-03-01 - 2016-03-31
2016-02-14 - 2016-02-29
2016-01-08 - 2016-01-24
2015-10-08 - 2015-10-08
2015-09-03 - 2015-09-25
2015-08-03 - 2015-08-29
2015-07-27 - 2015-07-31
2015-06-12 - 2015-06-12
2015-05-16 - 2015-05-16
2015-04-25 - 2015-04-25
2015-03-03 - 2015-03-07
2015-02-14 - 2015-02-22
2015-01-03 - 2015-01-25
2014-12-08 - 2014-12-08
2014-11-12 - 2014-11-27
2014-10-01 - 2014-10-30
2014-09-04 - 2014-09-29
2014-08-04 - 2014-08-14
2014-07-13 - 2014-07-24
2014-06-15 - 2014-06-29
2014-05-04 - 2014-05-25
2014-04-21 - 2014-04-26
2014-03-01 - 2014-03-16
2014-02-02 - 2014-02-26
2014-01-01 - 2014-01-26
2013-12-01 - 2013-12-26
2013-11-27 - 2013-11-30
2013-10-12 - 2013-10-17
2013-09-03 - 2013-09-15
2013-08-07 - 2013-08-31
2013-07-13 - 2013-07-23
2013-06-05 - 2013-06-19
2013-05-06 - 2013-05-31
2013-04-02 - 2013-04-30
2013-03-14 - 2013-03-28
2013-02-02 - 2013-02-27
2013-01-04 - 2013-01-30
2012-12-03 - 2012-12-31
2012-11-01 - 2012-11-30
2012-10-01 - 2012-10-31
2012-09-01 - 2012-09-29
2012-08-01 - 2012-08-27
2012-07-01 - 2012-07-30
2012-06-02 - 2012-06-28
2012-05-03 - 2012-05-30
2012-04-04 - 2012-04-26
2012-03-01 - 2012-03-09
2012-02-02 - 2012-02-29
2012-01-12 - 2012-01-31
 
关于本站 | 广告服务 | 联系我们 | 招聘信息 | 网站导航 | 隐私保护
Copyright (C) 1998-2024. Creaders.NET. All Rights Reserved.