設萬維讀者為首頁 萬維讀者網 -- 全球華人的精神家園 廣告服務 聯繫我們 關於萬維
 
首  頁 新  聞 視  頻 博  客 論  壇 分類廣告 購  物
搜索>> 發表日誌 控制面板 個人相冊 給我留言
幫助 退出
 
中國現代哲學家學會  
發現自己的絕對力量,它會震驚世界  
我的名片
中國現代哲學家學會
註冊日期: 2015-01-10
訪問總量: 1,883,489 次
點擊查看我的個人資料
Calendar
我的公告欄
最新發布
· ZT:數學要畢業了
· 為什麼中國有文化無文明
· 凡是說人工智能威脅人類,都是“
· 暴力打天下,是否應該永遠暴力治
· 為什麼90%以上的理工學人都是政
· 當前人工智能的危機是混淆了思維
· That AA Is can only be true if
友好鏈接
· hare:hare的博客
· bunny2:bunny2的博客
· InstanceTV:InstanceTV的博客
· Rabbit:Stinger 的博客
· microsoftbug:microsoftbug的博
分類目錄
【Mingcheng】
【心言】
· Free book: The Ontology of Nat
· 同學會會長關於哲學研究的對話(2
· 同學會會長關於哲學研究的對話
· 天下大勢
· 愛者共天地
· 死亡萬歲 -- 清明節留下的一縷思
· 重發: 哲學之愛從何而來?
· [中哲會]新程序啟動說明
· 哲學之愛從何而來?
【電視直播】
· USA-China in Depth (1)
· 《中哲會》TV直播頻道
【政治】
· 毛澤東的“民族解放”神話:專制
· 為什麼中國人反駁西方理論的觀點
· 台灣立足基礎-造原子彈
· 中國人缺乏理性會有什麼後果?
· 您願意選誰作為第一屆“網絡中華
· 中國未來的社會結構(2)
· 我建議在萬維上進行一次中國未來
· 川普現在唯一的願望是當個“前總
· 範例黨黨員章程
· 談中國民運的戰略與策略(範例黨
【傳統文化】
· 國學與西方思想的區別是狗尾與貂
· 必須立刻彈劾川普!
· 沒文化的鬼子
· 新年伊始中國“十馬奔騰”
· 扯住教皇不放—今天世界哪個國家
· 為什麼中國讀書人很難擺脫中國文
· 中國人的“感性邏輯”
· 也談“中國知識分子墮落”
· "現在打中國,輸贏無懸念&q
· 說!“你脫,還是不脫?!”
【深山蘭】
· 從二例看中國古代的思維方式
【其它】
· 語言與國家:俞興文明進步論的學
· 胡杰紀錄片:無人區畫展
· 美國為什麼偉大?- 只因為一個充
· 六四用一句話說
· 華人應該如何與西方人交往?(1)
· 中國人”也”是同歐洲人一樣的理
· 萬維有太多哲學誤導!
· 一月二十號白宮會發生哪一幕?
· 中國問題:文字
· 用事實駁斥中共關於朝鮮戰爭的謊
【比較政策】
· 階級分化的復甦
【一般】
· 中國為什麼不適合搞民主?
· 伯克利新名言:贏了-就是不認輸
· 什麼是今日美國社會的根本問題?
· 美國人打輸了還是朋友,中國人..
· 川普—你為什麼如此愚蠢?!
· 壓垮川普的最後一根稻草-喬治亞
· 看來川普...
· 中國對中國人的影響
· 中國文化在哪些方面體現了幼稚?
· 對中國人“批判”的看法 - 兼答
【遠方】
· 介紹一下荒誕論:遠方的孤獨
【何岸泉】
· 辯證法與放屁(ZT)
【哲學資料】
· 為相對主義辯護
· Instancology for Philosophers-
· Ten American Philosophers
· (1)馬克思和恩格思的“唯物主義
· Phenomenology of Spirit, Chapt
· 德國政府決定:在全球範圍對使用
· 為什麼人需要哲學?
· ZT:Rights
· Is your pet psychic?
· Twin Telepathy: Is there a ‘S
【中軍】
· 關於精神的問題
· 思維創新的哲學理解(下)
· 思維創新的哲學理解(上)
· 人生究竟是什麼
· 悟性創新的本性及閃失
· 悟性的創新及孩子的例證
· 怎樣進行討論
· 文字、語音、語義與創新
· 哲學研究能幹點兒啥
· 中國缺少創新的各種看法
【徒子】
· ZT:數學要畢業了
· 為什麼中國有文化無文明
· 凡是說人工智能威脅人類,都是“
· 暴力打天下,是否應該永遠暴力治
· 為什麼90%以上的理工學人都是政
· 當前人工智能的危機是混淆了思維
· That AA Is can only be true if
· 一群笨蛋!習近平連中國人腦袋都
· 凡存在必是相對並滅亡
· 科學的弊病在於其僅限於認識論
【嘎子】
· 關於丘成桐的講話的評論
· 已經轉到嘎子博客
· <二> 原本打算單獨寫一篇
· 哲學同真理的關係以及辯證法的本
【几子】
· What Will Happen to President
· 隨想:可口可樂
· 分形與卦像:漫話混沌,科學,與
· 淺議科學實證主義
存檔目錄
10/01/2026 - 10/31/2026
09/01/2026 - 09/30/2026
08/01/2026 - 08/31/2026
03/01/2026 - 03/31/2026
02/01/2026 - 02/28/2026
01/01/2026 - 01/31/2026
12/01/2025 - 12/31/2025
11/01/2025 - 11/30/2025
10/01/2025 - 10/31/2025
09/01/2025 - 09/30/2025
08/01/2025 - 08/31/2025
07/01/2025 - 07/31/2025
06/01/2025 - 06/30/2025
05/01/2025 - 05/31/2025
04/01/2025 - 04/30/2025
03/01/2025 - 03/31/2025
02/01/2025 - 02/28/2025
01/01/2025 - 01/31/2025
11/01/2024 - 11/30/2024
08/01/2024 - 08/31/2024
07/01/2024 - 07/31/2024
05/01/2024 - 05/31/2024
03/01/2024 - 03/31/2024
02/01/2024 - 02/29/2024
01/01/2024 - 01/31/2024
12/01/2023 - 12/31/2023
11/01/2023 - 11/30/2023
10/01/2023 - 10/31/2023
09/01/2023 - 09/30/2023
08/01/2023 - 08/31/2023
07/01/2023 - 07/31/2023
06/01/2023 - 06/30/2023
02/01/2023 - 02/28/2023
01/01/2023 - 01/31/2023
12/01/2022 - 12/31/2022
11/01/2022 - 11/30/2022
09/01/2022 - 09/30/2022
08/01/2022 - 08/31/2022
07/01/2022 - 07/31/2022
06/01/2022 - 06/30/2022
05/01/2022 - 05/31/2022
07/01/2021 - 07/31/2021
05/01/2021 - 05/31/2021
03/01/2021 - 03/31/2021
02/01/2021 - 02/28/2021
01/01/2021 - 01/31/2021
12/01/2020 - 12/31/2020
11/01/2020 - 11/30/2020
10/01/2020 - 10/31/2020
09/01/2020 - 09/30/2020
08/01/2020 - 08/31/2020
07/01/2020 - 07/31/2020
06/01/2020 - 06/30/2020
05/01/2020 - 05/31/2020
04/01/2020 - 04/30/2020
03/01/2020 - 03/31/2020
02/01/2020 - 02/29/2020
01/01/2020 - 01/31/2020
12/01/2019 - 12/31/2019
11/01/2019 - 11/30/2019
10/01/2019 - 10/31/2019
09/01/2019 - 09/30/2019
08/01/2019 - 08/31/2019
07/01/2019 - 07/31/2019
06/01/2019 - 06/30/2019
05/01/2019 - 05/31/2019
04/01/2019 - 04/30/2019
01/01/2018 - 01/31/2018
04/01/2016 - 04/30/2016
07/01/2015 - 07/31/2015
06/01/2015 - 06/30/2015
05/01/2015 - 05/31/2015
04/01/2015 - 04/30/2015
03/01/2015 - 03/31/2015
02/01/2015 - 02/28/2015
01/01/2015 - 01/31/2015
發表評論
作者:
用戶名: 密碼: 您還不是博客/論壇用戶?現在就註冊!
     
評論:
That AA Is can only be true if AA is not
   


That AA Is Can Only Be True If AA Is Not — and This Is Not Immunity

A recurring objection to Instancology concerns its most radical concept: the Absolute Absolute, or AA. If AA is said to be beyond Being and Nothing, beyond language, and outside the World-Instance, then a critic may immediately object: “You have simply made AA immune to criticism. Whenever someone asks what AA is, you reply that it cannot be described. Whenever someone asks for evidence, you reply that it lies beyond ordinary evidence. Whenever a contradiction appears, you say that AA transcends logic.”

If that were what Instancology did, the objection would be serious.

But it is not.

The proposition “AA IS and IS NOT” is not a protective wall erected around AA. It is the consequence of what “absolute” means when the demand for explanation is carried to its endpoint.

1. If AA Simply “Is,” It Cannot Be AA

Suppose we say:

AA is.

At first this appears to establish AA. In fact, it immediately creates a problem.

The moment “is” is used in its ordinary ontological sense, AA has been placed among things that are. It has acquired ontological status. We can then ask:

What kind of thing is AA?

Where does it belong?

What distinguishes it from other beings?

Under what conditions does it exist?

Why does it exist rather than not exist?

The supposed Absolute has therefore entered a framework within which it can be classified and explained. But anything situated within such a framework is already relative to that framework.

It is no longer Absolute Absolute.

Therefore, paradoxically:

If AA merely IS, AA is not AA.

This is why Instancology cannot stop with “AA is.”

2. But If AA Simply “Is Not,” There Is No AA

Now take the opposite proposition:

AA is not.

If this means straightforward nonexistence, the concept disappears. There is no Absolute, no terminus, and therefore no AA at all.

But the disappearance of AA recreates the problem that required it.

Every explanation then occurs within some explanatory background. That background either explains itself or depends upon another background. If it depends upon another, the question moves backward again. If it explains itself, we have already introduced something that does not receive its explanatory status from something beyond itself.

Thus the demand for explanation points toward a terminus that cannot itself be another ordinary member of the explanatory chain.

Consequently:

If AA simply IS NOT, AA cannot perform the function for which the concept is required.

We have reached the boundary.

AA cannot simply be.

AA cannot simply not be.

Hence:

AA IS and IS NOT.

3. “IS NOT” Makes “IS” Possible

The important point is easily missed.

“AA IS NOT” is not an additional qualification designed to save “AA IS.”

It is what makes “AA IS” possible.

If AA were positively identifiable as an existent, it would become something: an entity, principle, substance, law, structure, mind, God, Dao, One, energy, information, or mathematical object.

But every “something” permits differentiation:

this rather than that.

And differentiation introduces relation.

Once relation appears, absolute absoluteness has already been lost.

AA therefore remains Absolute only insofar as it is not what its own name appears to make it: an identifiable member of reality.

Its “not” is consequently not the negation of its “is.”

Its “not” protects the logical meaning of its “is.”

Or more strongly:

AA IS only because AA IS NOT.

4. Why This Is Not Immunity

An immunized theory works differently.

It normally begins with an ordinary factual claim. When contrary evidence appears, an auxiliary explanation is introduced so that no possible observation can count against the claim.

For example:

“The invisible object is in this room.”

Why can nobody detect it?

“Because it cannot be detected.”

Why does it have no effects?

“Because it produces no effects.”

Could anything show that it does not exist?

“No.”

Here, undetectability has been added merely to preserve the original assertion.

AA is structurally different.

Instancology does not first describe AA as an ordinary entity and then, after criticism, make it inaccessible. Its non-objecthood follows from the concept itself.

The argument is:

If AA can be completely objectified, classified, delimited, or placed inside a larger explanatory system, then it was never AA.

This is not an empirical excuse. It is a boundary condition on the concept.

There is nevertheless a legitimate challenge for Instancology. A critic can ask whether an explanatory terminus is really necessary; whether the regress must terminate; whether the four-domain ontology follows from that termination; whether the move from explanatory boundary to AA is justified; and whether the World-Instance can genuinely be derived from or related to AA.

Those are genuine criticisms.

What the critic cannot do is first accept the definition of AA as absolutely non-relative and then demand that AA become an ordinary object within a relational ontology without changing the subject.

5. AA Does Not Escape Contradiction; It Marks Its Origin

Ordinary logic distinguishes:

P

from

not-P.

Inside a determinate domain, asserting both normally generates contradiction.

But Instancology's claim is not simply:

“AA exists and AA does not exist in exactly the same respect.”

Rather, “IS” and “IS NOT” expose the failure of ordinary ontological predication at the boundary represented by AA.

AA IS means that the explanatory terminus cannot simply be eliminated.

AA IS NOT means that this terminus cannot itself become another entity requiring placement within the World-Instance.

Therefore AA is not halfway between existence and nonexistence. Nor is it a mysterious object possessing two contradictory properties.

The contradiction arises when language attempts to turn the precondition of ontological determination into another ontologically determined object.

That is precisely what AA forbids.

6. The Strongest Test of AA

For this reason, Instancology should not say:

“AA cannot be challenged.”

It should say the opposite:

Challenge the necessity of AA.

Show that explanation can be absolutely complete without presupposing any non-derived background.

Show that an infinite explanatory regress genuinely explains itself rather than indefinitely postponing explanation.

Show that the ultimate ground can be a determinate entity without thereby standing within some structure of determination.

Or show that no terminus whatsoever is required.

Any of these would strike at the argument for AA itself.

That is falsifiability at the conceptual level. What would not constitute a refutation is demanding an empirical specimen of AA, because the demand already converts AA into something the concept explicitly denies it to be.

Conclusion

AA does not survive because Instancology gives it immunity.

AA survives only if its paradox is necessary.

If AA simply IS, it becomes something and ceases to be Absolute Absolute.

If AA simply IS NOT, there is no terminus to the explanatory regress.

Thus the strange formulation is unavoidable:

AA IS and IS NOT.

And the deepest formulation is stronger still:

That AA IS can only be true because AA IS NOT.

The “NOT” is not a loophole through which AA escapes criticism. It is the very condition that prevents the Absolute from collapsing into another relative thing.

AA is therefore not protected from thought.

It is what thought encounters when thought reaches the boundary at which every “something” has already become too relative to be absolute.

 
關於本站 | 廣告服務 | 聯繫我們 | 招聘信息 | 網站導航 | 隱私保護
Copyright (C) 1998-2026. Creaders.NET. All Rights Reserved.