根據美國的政治體制,聯邦政府的權力是受限制的。中小學教育基本上是地方(學區)和州政府管轄的事務。但聯邦政府也提供一些教育經費來影響教育政策。1965年,聯邦政府制定了中小學教育法(Elementary and Secondary Education Act),對一些項目提供經費。這個法律幾經修改,在2001年在小布什總統的主導和國會的兩黨支持下形成了“不讓一個孩子掉隊”(No Child Left Behind,簡稱NCLB)法案,次年獲得通過。到2008年,美國教育部的總經費是572億美元【注1】,占聯邦可支配支出的5%。其中NCLB中主要項目的經費是222億美元【注2】。(2009,2010年因為經濟刺激法案,有關經費大幅度增加。不過這是不持久的。)
奧巴馬上任後,聲稱將對NCLB進行修改。2010年3月,教育部發布了名為“藍圖”的修改方案,但沒有正式提交國會。奧巴馬在最近的國情咨文中提出了“取代”NCLB,但沒有提供任何細節。最近,奧巴馬在聯邦預算提案中提出了對NCLB法案的修改。主要有:把州里制定的學校標準改為全國統一的標準,把原來2014年全部學生及格的目標改成“畢業生為讀大學和工作做好準備”,但具體定義尚未公布。以前奧巴馬還提到,要把“進步”而不是絕對成績作為評估標準。不知道這個是否包括進了目前的修改方案。另外,就是採用“登峰競賽(race to the top)”的做法,改變按學區和學生人數分配經費的辦法,由各州,各學區以競爭來獲得經費。目前,正式的修改提案何時能提出尚未可知。唯一可以確定的是,當這個修改提案到達國會後,又會引起一場教育理念和教育政策的全國辯論。
【1】 http://febp.newamerica.net/background-analysis/education-federal-budget 【2】 http://febp.newamerica.net/background-analysis/no-child-left-behind-funding 【3】 NCLB法案全文:http://www2.ed.gov/policy/elsec/leg/esea02/index.html 【4】 國會研究室(CRS)對NCLB的解釋:http://assets.opencrs.com/rpts/RL33960_20080108.pdf 【5】 “No Child Left Behind's 5th Anniversary Keeping Promises And Achieving Results”, US Department of Education, http://www2.ed.gov/nclb/overview/importance/nclb5anniversary.html 【6】 “What Can We Learn from the Implementation of No Child Left Behind?”, Rand Report 2010, http://www.rand.org/pubs/research_briefs/2010/RAND_RB9517.pdf 【7】 R. R. Skinner, “The No Child Left Behind Act: An Overview of Reauthorization Issues for the 111th Congress”, Congressional Research Service, May 27, 2009. http://leahy.senate.gov/imo/media/doc/The No Child Left Behind Act - An Overview of Reauthorization Issues for the 111th Congress.pdf 【8】 Murnane, Richard J., and John P. Papay. 2010. "Teachers' Views on No Child Left Behind: Support for the Principles, Concerns about the Practices." Journal of Economic Perspectives, 24(3): 151–66. http://www.aeaweb.org/articles.php?doi=10.1257/jep.24.3.151 【9】 Jolly, J., & Makel, M.. (2010). NO CHILD LEFT BEHIND: The Inadvertent Costs for High-Achieving and Gifted Students. Childhood Education, 87(1), 35-40. Retrieved January 29, 2011, from ProQuest Education Journals. (Document ID: 2184649061) 【10】 Whitehurst, G. J., (2010), February 4, 2011, Brookings Blog, http://www.brookings.edu/opinions/2010/0324_naep_whitehurst.aspx?p=1
Ouyang: 你的同事提到的這點是我想說但沒有提及的-- 大學的終身授予,是要經過嚴格的評估的,時間一般為六年,考核的內容包括教學,科研,和其他的professional development and services,而不是滿了年限就能自動獲得(而中小學的終身一般只需要兩三年probationary period,考核的標準也並不高)。當然,有了終身的教授,也可能從此“高枕無憂”,而不再努力工作,這種例子比比皆是,但學校也不能因為這個原因就把他們解僱,除非他們犯了非常嚴重的錯誤,比如性騷擾等。即便這樣,也會是一個漫長的過程,如果有教師工會的話就更是如此。所以從這個角度來講,說大學終身制是為了確保教授的質量,在得到終身之前大概可以這樣說,但對於拿到終身的人來講,它的真正目的其實更在於保護學術自由。
The following is an excerpt from Wikipedia regarding the primary reasons for academic tenure:
"Academic tenure is primarily intended to guarantee the right to academic freedom: it protects teachers and researchers when they dissent from prevailing opinion, openly disagree with authorities of any sort, or spend time on unfashionable topics. Thus academic tenure is similar to the lifetime tenure that protects some judges from external pressure. Without job security, the scholarly community as a whole might favor "safe" lines of inquiry. The intent of tenure is to allow original ideas to be more likely to arise, by giving scholars the intellectual autonomy to investigate the problems and solutions about which they are most passionate, and to report their honest conclusions.
"Universities also have economic rationales for adopting tenure systems. First, job security and the accompanying autonomy are significant employee benefits; without them, universities might have to pay higher salaries or take other measures to attract and retain talented or well-known scholars. Second, junior faculty are driven to establish themselves by the high stakes of the tenure decision (i.e., lifetime tenure vs. job loss), arguably helping to create a culture of excellence within the university. Finally, tenured faculty may be more likely to invest time in improving the universities where they expect to remain for life; they may also be more willing to hire, mentor and promote talented junior colleagues who could otherwise threaten their positions."
So in essence, there are three main incentives: protecting academic freedom, providing job security, and promote excellence (at least in the early, pre-tenure years).
關於德州教育作假的事件,是在NEWS WEEK上的一篇封面文章,有詳細的介紹,當時曾經轟動,也造成聯邦教育部長的辭職。 no child behind也被歸罪於此人,因為他是夸下了海口的。一般認為德州的高畢業率的真相即便是小布什(我覺得台灣的布殊,布希的說法很有趣,不會弄混,儘管把人家弄得好像不是一家子)也是被蒙在鼓裡。