-'The West' for the past 50 yrs only afforded HER PEOPLE to have progressive 'democracy' while not to the rest of 'the world citizens' -THREATS - How do ruling governments with MILITARY MIGHT deal with them to ensure the stability of their rule? -Chinese regime brutally cracked down on the protesters -Now the Iranian Islamic regime is doing the same -But what happens when the Western ruling powers feel threatened? -Chinese killed tens of thousands of her OWN people -Iranian dictator might kill similar number of her OWN people eventually -And US & her Allies? They killed hundreds of thousands of OTHER people - namely, innocent Koreans, Vietnamese, Iraqis citizens, etc... -They propped up dictatorial regimes (such as Pinochet in Chile & the Saudi Arabia King Abdullah...), outside USA they wage WARS AGAINST DEMOCRACY (remember Hamas's win in Gaza?) -That's the universal tactic to deal with THREATS, perceived or real -I don't like autocarcy. But we live in the real world. -There is no eternal friend, nor foe, but ONLY eternal INTEREST!
正如你所說,進步只能一步一步來。你提到的馬丁路德金,還有Rose Parks 是我真正敬佩的人。他們為爭取權益,有理有節地進行運動,沒有以個人私心(例如要當總統)綁架民眾,才有四十多年後的成就(奧巴馬當選總統)。如果他們也像學運領袖般以一己私利為目的,搞流血(別的學生的血)對抗,可能的結果就是事與願違。假如六四的領導能像馬丁路德金那樣處理,那是中國的民主發展之福,民眾之福。
64的失敗,不僅損失了一些年輕人,更使中國言論出版自由受到更嚴厲的限制。美國民權運動中廣泛報道的多起案件,The murder of Emmett till,Bombing of Birmingham church, Rosa Park jailed for refusing to give up her seat,MLKJr 領導的多次遊行與抵制運動, 使主流社會意識到社會的不公。實際上,民權運動使美國的民主自由大步前進。
前蘇聯的解體, like that of 大英帝國殖民統治的解體, is because the rulers in Kremlin and London did not treat other colonies or republican as their equal but their subordinates.
The United States, on the contrary, grant all the states joined later the same status as the original 13 states.
The fall-apart of 前蘇聯and 大英帝國 is not a matter of "if" but "When".
Crackingdown won't save either of these empires, just only makes situation nastier.
\"每一次給學生放Who killed Vincent Chin?,我都會在班上強忍眼淚,心裡的火總被燒起來\" I applaud your effort for the right of Asian American, which should not be shortchanged because you are one of them.
\"我在這裡幾乎每天瀏覽網上明報的主要消息,知道香港的情況。我看香港人不是不知道當時的實情,而是一種不願回歸的情結。那些所謂的學生領袖和智囊們也只有和香港有些人是一個願打一個願挨。\" ----------------------------- I just don\'t understand why you dismiss the stance of most 香港人, their 良知丶尊嚴和是非黑白之心 because 香港人 have a interest in a democratic China?!
I respectively disagree the idea that cracking down 6.4 help China 存在和穩定. On the contrary, the reason for 前蘇聯解體 is that many many crack downs in the era of 前蘇聯 built up the discontent and hatred of other oppressed ethnic groups. It is a vocalnic erruption waiting to happen. Cracking down on Tibetian, in my view, will not provide 穩定, but just grow the problem and brew the discontent.
For example, if US cracks down on the Civil Movement, it may transiently silence people but will aggravate racial tension in the long run.